How do you choose a hot water tank? It comes down to three things: the fuel type (gas, electric, or tankless), the right size for your household, and your budget for upfront cost versus running cost. Get those three right and you’ll have reliable hot water that fits your home for years.

Mr Swirl The Friendly Plumber has been helping homeowners and businesses choose and install hot water tanks for over 25 years across Greater Vancouver and the Fraser Valley, including Vancouver, Burnaby, Coquitlam, Port Coquitlam, Port Moody, Surrey, Langley, Maple Ridge, New Westminster, Richmond, Delta and Abbotsford. If you need a hand, we’re just a call away.

Plumber Inspecting A Hot Water Tank In A Coquitlam Home

Not sure which tank fits your home? You don’t have to guess. A quick chat with a local plumber can match a tank to your household in minutes. Call 604-435-4664 any time.

The 3 things to decide before you buy

  1. Fuel type — gas, electric, or tankless.
  2. Size — enough hot water for your household, without waste.
  3. Budget — a lower price today, or lower bills over time.

Let’s take them one at a time.

Step 1: Choose your fuel type

Gas hot water tank. A gas burner heats the water. Gas tanks reheat quickly and cost less to run, which is great for busy households. They need venting — a safe path for exhaust to leave your home — so they work best where gas and a vent are already set up.

Electric hot water tank. Uses heating elements instead of a flame. No venting needed, so it’s simpler and cheaper to install. The trade-off: it costs more to run and reheats more slowly. A good fit for smaller homes or lighter hot water use.

Tankless water heater. A tankless water heater skips the storage tank and heats water only when you turn on the tap. It never runs out for normal use and lasts much longer. The catch: it costs more upfront, and one unit can struggle if you run several hot taps at once.

Gas tank Electric tank Tankless
Upfront cost Moderate Lowest Highest
Running cost Lower Higher Lowest
Reheat speed Fast Slower Instant (flow-limited)
Lifespan 8–12 yrs 8–12 yrs 15–20 yrs
Venting needed Yes No Yes (gas models)
Best for Larger households Smaller households Efficiency-focused homes

Step 2: Choose the right size

Size is about how much hot water your home uses at once. Standard tanks come in 40, 50, or 60 gallons. A simple guide:

  • 40 gallons — 1 to 2 people
  • 50 gallons — 3 to 4 people
  • 60+ gallons — 5 or more people, or a home with several bathrooms running at the same time

A tank that’s too small runs out mid-shower. One that’s too big wastes energy keeping water hot that nobody uses. If your household has grown or you often run out of hot water, size up when you replace.

Hot Water Tank Installed With Plumbing Connections In A Coquitlam Home

Counting people and bathrooms gets you close, but the safest way to size a tank is to have a plumber look at your real usage. Get a sizing recommendation before you buy.

Step 3: Weigh upfront cost vs. running cost

Cheaper today isn’t always cheaper overall. Here’s the pattern:

  • Electric tanks cost the least to buy but the most to run.
  • Gas tanks cost a bit more upfront and less to run.
  • Tankless costs the most upfront but the least to run, and lasts the longest.

A high-efficiency tank or a tankless system may qualify for rebates through FortisBC, which helps close the gap on the upfront cost. Prices depend on the type, size, and your home’s setup, so we don’t guess — we give you a firm number after a quick look.

Hot water tanks in Coquitlam homes: what’s different

Where you live shapes the right choice more than most people expect:

  • Older neighbourhoods — homes in Maillardville, Austin Heights, and Central Coquitlam were often built in the gas-tank era, with venting and gas lines already in place. Switching to electric or tankless here can mean extra electrical or venting work.
  • Newer developments — many Burke Mountain and Westwood Plateau homes are already set up for high-efficiency or tankless systems, which makes that upgrade easier.
  • Strata and townhomes — Coquitlam has a lot of stratified housing, and many buildings have rules about tank type, permits, and who does the work. Check with your strata before you buy.
  • Permits and code — water heater replacements in BC generally need a permit and must meet current code, especially for gas venting.

This is why “just buy the same one again” isn’t always the best move — your neighbourhood’s era and setup matter as much as your household size.

Storage tank or tankless: which is right for you?

  • Choose a storage tank if you want a lower upfront cost, a simple swap, and steady hot water for a typical household.
  • Choose tankless if you want the lowest running cost, endless hot water for normal use, the longest lifespan, and you don’t often run many hot taps at once.

Still torn? That’s normal — it’s a real trade-off, and the best answer depends on your home. We’re happy to walk you through it with no pressure.

High-Efficiency Tankless Water Heater Installed In A Greater Vancouver Home

What you can decide yourself — and what a plumber should confirm

You can do this on your own:

  • Count the people and bathrooms in your home.
  • Notice whether you currently run out of hot water.
  • Check whether you have gas or electric now.
  • Look up current FortisBC rebates.

Leave this to a licensed plumber:

  • Confirming your gas line and venting can support the tank you want. By law in BC, gas work must be done by a licensed gas fitter under Technical Safety BC rules.
  • Checking your electrical panel can handle an electric or tankless unit.
  • Pulling the permit and installing to code.
  • Final sizing based on your real usage.

What to Do Next

If you know your household size and current setup, you’re already most of the way to a good choice. The last step is confirming your home can support the tank you want — venting for gas, panel capacity for electric or tankless — and getting it installed to code.

When you’re ready, Mr Swirl can recommend the right tank and handle the hot water tank installation in Coquitlam and across the Lower Mainland. And if your current tank is getting old, our guide to the signs it’s time to replace your tank will help you plan the timing.

FAQ

How do I choose the right hot water tank? Decide on three things: fuel type (gas, electric, or tankless), the right size for your household, and your budget for upfront versus running cost. A plumber can confirm your home supports your choice.

What size hot water tank do I need? As a rough guide: 40 gallons for 1–2 people, 50 for 3–4, and 60+ for 5 or more or homes running several fixtures at once. Your real usage sets the final size.

Is a gas or electric hot water tank better? Gas costs a little more upfront but runs cheaper and reheats faster, which suits larger homes. Electric is cheaper to install and needs no venting — a good fit for smaller households.

Are tankless water heaters worth it? For efficiency-focused homes without heavy simultaneous use, yes. They cost more upfront but use the least energy, never run out for normal use, and last 15–20 years.

How much does a hot water tank cost in BC? It depends on the type, size, and your home’s setup, so a firm price needs a quick inspection. High-efficiency and tankless systems may qualify for FortisBC rebates that lower the cost.

Which hot water tank is best for a family? Larger families usually do best with a 50–60 gallon gas tank for fast reheat, or a properly sized tankless system if they want the lowest running cost and don’t run many hot taps at once.

Final Answer

How to choose a hot water tank comes down to three decisions: pick the fuel type (gas for fast, cheaper-to-run heat; electric for a simple, low-cost install; tankless for the lowest running cost and longest life), match the size to your household (40/50/60 gallons for small/medium/large homes), and weigh upfront cost against running cost.

The safest step before you buy is to have a licensed plumber confirm your home can support your choice — the right venting for gas, or panel capacity for electric or tankless — and pull the proper permit. If your old tank is already leaking, treat that as urgent: shut off the water to it if it’s safe and call right away.

Whenever you’re ready, Mr Swirl will recommend the right tank and handle the hot water tank installation for you. Call 604-435-4664 or book online — we’re here 24/7.